“Feedback is the breakfast of champions.” – Ken Blanchard

 

 Imagine your team as a high-performance race car, finely tuned, efficient, and constantly evolving. The secret ingredient that fuels this evolution? Effective feedback. Just like athletes need proper nutrition, your team requires insightful feedback to push past plateaus and reach their full potential, as Ken Blanchard reminds us.

But let’s face it, feedback can be a double-edged sword. Delivered poorly, it can demotivate, discourage, and create unnecessary tension, which is why so many of us dread feedback sessions, viewing them as uncomfortable confrontations rather than opportunities for growth and learning. However, when wielded skilfully, it transforms into a powerful tool for empowerment and development.

And studies have consistently shown that organisations that prioritise feedback outperform their competitors. By actively seeking and embracing feedback, they establish a culture of learning and adaptation, allowing them to navigate challenges and seize opportunities effectively. As leaders, it is our responsibility to recognise the power of feedback and harness it to unlock the full potential of our teams.

This month, as we continue our exploration of “Executing Effectively,” we explore the art of “Giving Productive Feedback.” Following the threads of decisive leadership, delegation, and the strategic use of KPIs and OKRs, together with effective meetings, we explore the critical role that feedback plays in fostering a culture of continuous improvement, aligning performance with organisational goals, and propelling businesses towards success. With insights drawn from real-life examples and practical strategies, this article could transform the way you view, give, and receive feedback.

The Essence of Productive Feedback

In a world where business dynamics evolve at breakneck speed, the ability to give and receive feedback effectively becomes not just a skill but a critical organisational lifeline. But what makes feedback productive rather than just a routine exchange of observations or, worse, a demotivating critique?

First and foremost, productive feedback is constructive. It’s designed to build up, not tear down. It focuses on actions and behaviours that can be changed or improved, rather than on personal traits. Imagine a sales team member who’s missed their target for the third consecutive month. Telling them they’re simply not cut out for sales is neither helpful nor constructive. Instead, productive feedback would involve analysing the sales approach, discussing potential areas for improvement, and setting tangible, achievable goals to help them succeed.

Moreover, productive feedback is specific. General comments like “You need to do better” or “Great job” are too vague to be useful. Effective feedback zeroes in on particular instances or behaviours. For example, saying, “Your presentation to the board was compelling because you backed up your arguments with solid data and responded confidently to their questions,” provides clear insight into what was done well and why it was effective.

Productive feedback is also actionable. It gives the recipient a clear direction on how to improve. It’s not enough to highlight a problem area; productive feedback involves suggesting steps or strategies for improvement. For instance, if a team member struggles with time management, don’t just point out their missed deadlines. Discuss strategies like prioritising tasks, using time management tools, or delegating non-essential tasks.

Equally important, productive feedback is timely. Feedback given months after the fact loses its relevance and impact. Immediate or close-to-the-event feedback ensures that the details are fresh and the learning opportunity is maximised. It’s like the difference between correcting course mid-journey, or after you’ve arrived at the wrong destination.

Lastly, feedback must be empowering. It should leave the recipient feeling capable of making the suggested improvements, and motivated to do so. This requires a balance of highlighting strengths while addressing areas for growth. It’s about fostering a mindset that views feedback as an opportunity for development rather than criticism.

In essence, productive feedback is the cornerstone of effective execution. It’s the mechanism through which we guide our teams and ourselves towards continuous improvement and operational excellence. It nurtures an environment where mistakes are seen as learning opportunities, where every challenge is a step towards mastery, and where every individual feels valued and understood.

As leaders, mastering the art of giving and receiving productive feedback is not just a skill—it’s our responsibility. It requires empathy, patience, and clarity. But most importantly, it requires an unwavering commitment to the growth and success of our people. After all, in the grand scheme of business and leadership, feedback isn’t just the breakfast of champions—it’s the daily bread that sustains and propels us forward.

Strategies for Delivering Effective Feedback

Delivering feedback that not only resonates but also motivates action, requires a thoughtful approach. It’s an art form, balancing honesty with empathy, and guidance with empowerment. Here are some strategies that can help make your feedback more effective, ensuring it acts as a catalyst for growth and improvement.

Environment Matters

When giving feedback, consider the environment – choosing an appropriate setting for feedback can be as crucial as the content itself. A neutral, private setting ensures a safe space for open dialogue, free from external anxieties.

Start with a Positive Foundation

Begin your feedback sessions on a positive note. Acknowledging what an individual or team has done well sets a constructive tone for the conversation. It opens the recipient’s mind to receive feedback, reducing defensive barriers. For instance, if you’re providing feedback on a project, highlight the aspects that were handled exceptionally well before addressing areas for improvement. This approach underscores that your intent is to build on strengths, not just critique weaknesses.

Be Specific and Objective

Vagueness is the enemy of effective feedback. “You’re not being proactive enough” is less helpful than, “I noticed you’ve been hesitant to take the lead in the last few team meetings, and as a result, we’re missing out on your valuable insights.” Specific examples provide a clear understanding of what needs to change and why. They also demonstrate that your feedback is based on observable facts, not subjective opinions.

Focus on Behaviour, Not Personality

Effective feedback targets behaviours or actions, not personal attributes. Criticising someone’s character (“You’re so disorganised”) is not only hurtful but also unproductive. Instead, focus on specific behaviours that can be changed (“Your workspace seems cluttered, which might be affecting your efficiency. How about we look into some organisation strategies?”). This keeps the conversation positive and focused on improvement.

Provide Actionable Advice

Feedback should be a roadmap, not just a reflection. After identifying areas for improvement, discuss specific, actionable steps that can be taken to address them. Whether it’s adopting a new strategy, learning a new skill, or adjusting a workflow, actionable feedback empowers the recipient to make positive changes. Moreover, offering to support them through these changes can further motivate and encourage them.

Encourage a Two-Way Dialogue

Feedback is most effective when it’s a two-way street. Encourage the recipient to share their thoughts and feelings about the feedback. This not only helps them process the information but also provides valuable insights into their perspective. It can also uncover underlying issues that may be affecting their performance. By fostering a dialogue, you create a collaborative environment where feedback is shared openly and constructively.

Follow Up

Feedback doesn’t end with a conversation. Following up after a feedback session shows that you’re invested in the individual’s growth and improvement. It also provides an opportunity to discuss progress, reassess goals, and to make adjustments as necessary. Regular check-ins reinforce the importance of the feedback and the commitment to ongoing development.

Creating a Culture of Continuous Feedback

In the quest for organisational excellence, creating a culture that embraces continuous feedback is pivotal. Such a culture doesn’t emerge by chance; it is carefully cultivated through intentional actions and behaviours by leaders at all levels and is a core component of the overall company culture.

Here’s how you can foster an environment where feedback is not just accepted but sought after, serving as the backbone of effective execution and growth.

Lead by Example

The journey towards a feedback-rich culture starts at the top. Leaders must not only provide constructive feedback but also actively seek it for themselves. When you, as a leader, ask for feedback on your decisions, management style, or the support you provide your team, you’re demonstrating that feedback is a tool for improvement, regardless of position or status. This openness sets a powerful precedent, showing that feedback is a part of growth and learning for everyone in the organisation.

Make Feedback Routine, Not an Event

Feedback should be as natural and regular as any other daily activity in your organisation. Integrate feedback into your regular interactions and processes, such as during team meetings, one-on-one check-ins, and even informal conversations. The more embedded it becomes in the day-to-day operations, the less daunting it will feel, encouraging a more open and ongoing exchange of ideas and observations.

Establish Clear Channels for Feedback

A culture of continuous feedback thrives on clarity and accessibility. Establish clear channels through which feedback can be given and received. This could include regular feedback sessions, anonymous feedback tools for more sensitive issues, and open-door policies that encourage spontaneous feedback exchanges. Ensuring that these channels are known and accessible to all members of the organisation is crucial for fostering an environment where feedback is freely shared.

Educate on the Art of Feedback

Understanding how to give and receive feedback is essential for a feedback-rich culture. Invest in training and resources that teach your team the principles of constructive feedback. Highlight the importance of specificity, objectivity, and empathy in feedback exchanges. Equipping your team with these skills not only enhances the quality of feedback but also its effectiveness in driving growth and improvement.

Celebrate Feedback Successes

Recognising and celebrating instances where feedback has led to positive changes or achievements reinforces its value. Share stories of how feedback has helped solve problems, improve processes, or enhance performance. This not only highlights the practical benefits of feedback but also encourages more people to engage in the feedback process, seeing it as a positive force within the organisation.

Address Feedback in a Timely Manner

The impact of feedback is significantly heightened when it is acted upon swiftly. When feedback is given, ensure there is a clear plan for how it will be addressed. This doesn’t mean every piece of feedback will result in immediate change, but it should be acknowledged and considered. Quick action demonstrates that feedback is taken seriously and can lead to meaningful improvements, further embedding the value of feedback within the organisational culture.

Feedback in Action – Real-World Examples

The theory behind productive feedback is compelling, but its true power is revealed through action. Real-world examples illustrate not only the transformative impact of feedback but also how it can be applied effectively across different contexts. Here are a few instances from experiences where feedback acted as a catalyst for change and success.

Case Study 1: Revitalising a Project Team

A project team was struggling with missed deadlines and low morale, significantly impacting their deliverables. Through a series of feedback sessions, it was identified that unclear roles and lack of accountability were major roadblocks. Specific, actionable feedback was provided to each team member, clarifying their responsibilities and how they contributed to the overall project goals. Regular check-ins were instituted, providing a forum for ongoing feedback. The result was a notable improvement in team performance, project delivery times, and, most importantly, team morale. This example underscores the importance of clear, actionable feedback in driving team success.

Case Study 2: Leadership Transformation

A seasoned leader, known for their top-down management style, received feedback during a 360-degree review process that highlighted the team’s desire for more collaborative leadership. Taking this feedback to heart, the leader embarked on a coaching journey to develop a more inclusive leadership approach. By soliciting feedback regularly from the team on this transformation and adapting based on their input, the leader was able to foster a more engaged and productive team environment. This shift not only enhanced team dynamics but also improved overall performance, showcasing the impact of feedback on personal growth and leadership development.

Case Study 3: Enhancing Client Satisfaction

Feedback doesn’t just drive internal improvements; it’s also crucial in refining client-facing processes. After receiving consistent feedback from clients about the complexity of the reporting process, a company undertook a comprehensive review and redesign of their client reports. By incorporating specific suggestions from the feedback, the reports became more streamlined and user-friendly. Subsequent feedback from clients noted a significant improvement in satisfaction levels, highlighting how feedback can directly contribute to enhancing service quality and client relationships.

Conclusion: The Cumulative Power of Feedback

As we’ve explored throughout this article, feedback is far more than a managerial obligation or a routine exchange of critiques. It’s a dynamic tool that, when wielded with intention and care, can foster profound growth, innovation, and success. From revitalising teams and transforming leadership styles to enhancing client satisfaction, the examples we’ve looked at underscore the versatile and transformative nature of feedback.

When seeking to execute effectively, feedback serves as both a compass and a catalyst. It guides us towards our goals with clarity and precision, while also propelling us forward, pushing us to continuously improve and adapt. As leaders, our role is not just to provide feedback but to create an environment where feedback is woven into the very fabric of our organisational culture. It’s about championing a mindset where feedback is eagerly given and received, where each piece of feedback is viewed as a golden opportunity for growth. And remember, too, the studies that show the performance advantages of a strong feedback culture.

Integrating feedback into our leadership and organisational practices is about committing to a culture where feedback is not feared but celebrated, where it’s not an end but a beginning. The path to executing effectively is paved with feedback, each piece a stepping stone towards excellence.

 

Now it’s your turn: What has been your most impactful feedback experience, and how did it shape your approach to leadership and execution? Share your experiences, insights, and strategies in the comments below.

———-

This is the final article in this month’s focus on Executing Effectively – the other articles can be read from the links below.

Or, better still, subscribe to my blog and receive the latest articles automatically, simply by clicking here.

Previous articles in this series:

• Mastering Decisive Leadership: The Keystone of Effective Execution
• Delegating for Success: The Leader’s Path to Effective Execution
• Harnessing the Power of KPIs and OKRs for Effective Execution
• Conquering Meetings: Transforming them into Engines of Execution Excellence

And, if you’d like learn more related to execution, and feedback, the following articles and posts might also be of interest.

Related Posts

• 3 Things You Must Do to Keep Your Top Performers and Your Company in Great Shape for the New World of Work
• How Many of These 7 Leadership Questions Can You Say Yes To?
• The Best Leaders Will Do This In 2022
• Time Management for Busy Executives
• Leadership is the capacity to translate vision into reality.’ – Warren Bennis
• Why Am I So Busy But Can’t Seem to Get Anything Done?
• Mastering Time Management: Escaping the Urgency Trap for Leadership Success
• Are You Scheduling Me Time Into Your Day?
• “Sometimes our stop-doing list needs to be bigger than our to-do list.”- Patti Digh
• “Half of the troubles of this life can be traced to saying yes too quickly and not saying no soon enough.” – Josh Billings

Backgrounders

Forbes – Why Asking For Feedback Can Be A Key To Success

HBR – How to Give (and Receive) Critical Feedback

Fast Company: The definitive guide to giving actually helpful feedback

• The importance of incorporating customer feedback

———–

Working together to take your business to new heights!

With over 50 years of experience in the technology industry, spanning three continents, and three decades in CxO roles driving exceptional growth in revenue and profitability, I now work with and coach other business owners and CxOs to reach even greater heights.

Let’s talk about your business goals and challenges, strategy, culture, leadership, board dynamics, emerging trends, joining a peer advisory group and anything else that can accelerate your business growth. Book a complimentary 30-minute call with me today!

Unlock the full potential of your business – and schedule your call now!

P.S. If you’ve enjoyed this post and would like to subscribe to my blog simply enter your details here or drop me a note by just clicking here.

#BusinessFitness #Action #Accountability #Coaching #Execution #Feedback #Growth #Meetings #Motivation #Leadership #Productivity #Success #Teams #QOTW