I’m going to try not to make this too much of a rant, but I’m both extremely disappointed and annoyed – not for me personally (thankfully I wasn’t directly affected), but for the thousands of people who’ve had their holiday plans, reunions and Christmas spoilt through a combination of woeful ineptitude and greed.
And, I think, there’s a real danger of this ineptitude and greed having long-term effects that are several orders of magnitude more serious for the country as a whole.
I’m talking here, for those of you who’ve not yet guessed, about BAA and Heathrow.
How can a company entrusted with managing the world’s busiest international airport be so unprepared for winter? It’s certainly not through lack of money – BAA is on track for an operating income of nearly £1 billion this year, and yet their total expenditure on preparing for snow and winter conditions this year was just £500 000… (an amount the board has just allowed to be increased to £10 million – still only 1% of their operating profit!). In my view this is a typical case of short-term profit focus, at the expense of long-term sustainability (see my post: The Perils of Quarteritis).
It’s not as if they didn’t have warning. The first cold snap hit at the end of November and there were already warnings that heavy snow and icy conditions could be expected for the rest of the year. Granted, by then it was probably too late to have been able to source much new equipment in time (although they should have learned a lesson from January & February), but they put no contingency plans in place at all.
What about a deal with farmers nearby to use their tractors and grading equipment in an emergency? What about stockpiling grit, salt, glycol, etc.? Then they compounded things by turning down offers of help to clear the runways and taxiways from the military.
And, on top of this, they apparently gave out poor information to airlines such as BA which could have operated more flights than they did, and so reduce the backlog somewhat.
So, this corporate greed and ineptitude directly ruined the holidays for thousands of people, apart from costing hard-pressed airlines a good deal of money (can they sue BAA?)…
But the long-term effects could be even more serious. With some 30 million people a year visiting Britain, annual tourism expenditure of some £90 billion and almost 8% of jobs supported by tourism, this is a vital sector of the economy. However, the unreliability of British airports – especially one as important as Heathrow – is bound to make travellers think twice about using Britain as a stopover point, or even as a destination.
And airports in the Middle East such as Dubai and Qatar are eager to take these passengers. For example, Dubai is already the 4th busiest international airport in the world, with huge expansion already underway, and one of the youngest fleets in the world (and a flexible one, as Emirates was apparently able to put on 3 extra flights a day to clear their backlog once Heathrow reopened).
The impact of a diversion of disgruntled passengers from Heathrow to Dubai, for example, would have an enormous impact on Britain and on the struggling BA.
BAA needs to wake up, stop being so greedy and to accept proper responsibility for its role in running strategically important airports – or it needs to be replaced by a company that will do so, and quickly.
What do you think – should the company, its leadership, or both be replaced?
- BAA in war of words with BA as Heathrow disruption continues (independent.co.uk)
- Inquiry into Heathrow snow chaos (bbc.co.uk)
- Heathrow officials say recovery from snow chaos is under way (guardian.co.uk)
- More snow forecast for Europe (windsorstar.com)
Welcome to Europe Guy. The same thing happens every year even in countries like Sweden, Norway and other countries where it is a certainty that it will snow.
Lived in London for 15 years and it’s actually not often it snows. Agree with you that they should expect it and be prepared to deal with it when it happens. But the likelyhood of that happening is next to none. So just get used to it because it will happen again and again and again, unfortunately.
Thanks for the comment, but as I understand it other airports don’t close completely after a few inches of snow (I believe it was no more than 6 inches / 15cm). Snow storms will cause delays as separation times/distances of aircraft need to increase, but I’ve flown into Germany in much more snow that this, with no problems.
The issue is that BAA have simply not bothered to try to prepare themselves (there were more snow storms in Jan / Feb this year and they didn’t learn from these!), nor even put contingency plans in place “just in case.”
Frankly, as I see it, this is little more than gross negligence on their part…