“It is not enough to be industrious; so are the ants. What are you industrious about?” – Henry David Thoreau, letter to H. G. O. Blake, 16 November 1857
The Second Late Friday
It’s the second Friday running that the team’s still there past six, getting a shipment out the door, and the owner notices it on the way out to the car. There’s a flicker of something before the pride kicks in, a question to himself about whether this is becoming normal, whether anyone’s said anything, whether it’s fair to keep asking this of people who’ve already given a full week. It passes. The job got done, the client’s happy, and there’s a real satisfaction in that.
It’s only later, in the car, that a second and quite different thought arrives. This is the fourth or fifth week this quarter that’s ended like this. The business is doing more than it did this time last year, and everyone can feel it. What isn’t obvious, sitting at a red light with the radio on, is whether any of it is actually worth more.
The Instinct to Work Harder
Effort is a lever every leader already knows how to pull. It shows in late meetings, overflowing inboxes, urgent calls and people stepping in to rescue customers. It can be praised, managed and, when necessary, demanded. When results disappoint, the automatic response is to ask for more of it, because effort is visible, immediate and entirely within a leader’s control in a way that margin never quite is. Margin arrives later, aggregated into a report, with no obvious thread connecting it back to the hundreds of small decisions that actually produced it.
Underneath that sits something closer to a habit than a decision. The client who calls asking for something extra, the deadline that’s moved up, the favour that needs answering today, all of it arrives loudly, and answering it feels like leadership, it feels like providing great service. The subtler question, whether this particular piece of work is worth what it will cost to deliver, rarely arrives with the same urgency, so it waits.
It isn’t that the question gets refused. It simply never quite gets its turn, because something louder is always standing in front of it. Give that pattern enough weeks and a business can end up entirely staffed by people responding well to whatever shouted loudest that day, with nobody left to ask what any of it was actually worth.
There’s a reason that matters more than it first appears. The things that make the most noise are rarely the things anyone has priced. A rush job, a favour, a fix done under pressure, all tend to get done at whatever margin happens to survive the effort of doing it quickly. Sometimes that’s none. Sometimes it’s less than none, because putting something right that should have been right the first time costs the business twice, yet the rescue itself is remembered more clearly than the economics behind it.
Where the Work Stops Paying
It rarely appears as one spectacular commercial mistake. It builds through small additions that each look reasonable on their own: the extra report, the customised process, the special delivery arrangement, the experienced person who always joins the call, the service that began as a favour and gradually became expected. None of these decisions felt careless at the time. Most of them felt like good service.
Legacy customers offer a recognisable version of the same pattern. Their price may still reflect the relationship the business first sold, while the work now includes years of accumulated exceptions, heavier compliance demands and more internal coordination than anyone remembers agreeing to. The relationship is often genuinely valued, and the work is often still done well. It’s simply no longer priced for what it now involves, and nobody can point to the moment that stopped being true.
None of this is inefficiency, and it’s worth being clear about that. Whether the price still reflects what delivery now involves is a separate question from whether the work is being done properly, and the two get confused more often than they should. A business can tighten every process it has, control costs at every turn, and still be losing money on work that’s executed beautifully.
Good Work With the Wrong Economics
There’s a different question sitting in the same territory: why agreed work sometimes doesn’t happen at all, why the room nods and the agreement fails to become action, evaporating somewhere between the meeting and the following month. The problem here is a separate one. Here, the work does happen, and does so on time, to a good standard, with a satisfied client at the end of it. Execution discipline gets things done, but has never claimed to decide whether those things were worth doing in the first place, and it isn’t clear who’s responsible for that aspect.
A business proud of its on-time delivery record can, in the very same year, watch its margin thin without anyone noticing the connection. A difficult piece of work gets accepted somewhere in a sales conversation, priced on instinct or on pressure to win the account, and nobody downstream ever asks again whether the number covered what it turned out to cost. The authority to decide what work gets accepted, and at what price, sits somewhere in many businesses. In quite a few, it doesn’t sit anywhere in particular, which often results in margin leakage.
The Comfort of Being Busy
Busyness is rewarded because it’s visible. A full diary, a loaded delivery schedule, a team that’s clearly stretched all look like health from the outside, and they’re rarely questioned, partly because slowing down to examine them can feel like admitting weakness. The late Fridays from the start of this belong here too, not as something to resolve, just as the same instinct wearing a different coat: the thing that looks most like commitment is often the hardest thing to ask a tough question of.
Over time, a business becomes genuinely skilled at serving a collection of exceptions. The effort involved is real, and often impressive to watch. But every variation carries coordination, judgement and interruption that may never show up in the original price, and more people become busy simply maintaining work the business stopped treating as a choice long ago.
Research into product and service complexity suggests this cost travels further than the point where the complexity was introduced, drawing in sales, operations, administration and leadership attention in ways the original decision never accounted for. A business would generally find it harder to stand up and say “we did less this year, and made more” than to explain away a difficult quarter, even when the first sentence might be the truer one.
What a Margin-First Week Might Show
Go back to that ordinary week, but read it through margin instead of effort. The full diary doesn’t disappear. The urgent customer is still urgent, the recovery still heroic. But their meaning shifts. Some of that week represents genuinely valuable work carried out under real pressure. Other parts of it may reveal a business effectively subsidising a customer, a piece of complexity or an inherited commitment with the effort of its own people, and doing so without ever having formally decided to.
This isn’t a call to instrument every hour or cost every favour, and it wouldn’t survive the attempt. It’s closer to a habit some businesses seem to have and most don’t: the habit of understanding, at the level of the customer or the piece of work, which activity is actually paying for itself and which is being carried by everything else. A leader asked directly which piece of last month’s work actually made money can usually answer for the big contract. Fewer can answer for the ordinary Tuesday, and it’s the ordinary Tuesdays that fill most of the calendar.
There’s a different reading of what a business is worth sitting underneath this same question, one step further along than this article needs to go, but important enough that it’s worth recognising in passing.
The Half of the Week Nobody Measures
The business in all of this hasn’t done anything wrong, exactly. It has simply been measuring the wrong half of its own week, the half that’s easy to see and easy to feel good about, while the half that actually determines whether the year was worth having stays out of view until the accounts arrive. The problem is rarely the people doing the work, and it would be a mistake to read any of this as a comment on them. It’s what the business has agreed to do, and for how much, decision by decision, over a long enough stretch of ordinary weeks that nobody remembers making most of those decisions.
Pushing harder can still improve this month’s result. It usually does, which is exactly why it stays the instinct of choice. But it also asks good people to compensate repeatedly for choices they didn’t necessarily make and might not have made the same way.
If effort keeps rising while margin doesn’t, the question may no longer be how much more the team can do. It may be what the business has been asking all that effort to produce, and what it agreed, somewhere along the way, to accept in return.
If you enjoyed this article you can subscribe here to receive future articles.
—
0 Comments